Topic: Dogawful Premier League/Championship/English Officiating

[YANKEEBLEEDSMAGPIE]

I'd like to inaugurate Mike Dean as the first winner of the Dodgy c*** Ref of the Week award.  The yellow to David Luiz shows one (or more) of three things:

1) He is biased in favor of Chelsea
2) He doesn't know the last man rule
3) He doesn't have the balls to make the right call

Any of the three should really be grounds for him to have to find a new line of work. 

Shocking for sure, but only insofar as this type of s*** happens all the time in English footy, generally in favor of the clubs that spend the £££.

[Stottie]

If you could the penalty last week and the corner in the Wigan game the one before, that's three howlers in three weeks.

[WarrenBartonCentrePartin]

Gullit at HT on the Luiz incident,

'Well, I don't know the rule..... Well I do, but...'.   Idiot.

[Decky]

This will be Mike Dean's award every week.

[Pilko]

I have absolutely no idea how the Luiz one isn't a red card. It's a f***ing disgustingly bad decision. I hope Dean gets cock rot.

[Kid Icarus]

Well it's taken until December for this to be talked about, so it can't have been that bad since August.

[ObiChrisKenobi]

http://www.newcastle-online.org/nufcforum/index.php/topic,71852.msg2546660.html#msg2546660
http://www.newcastle-online.org/nufcforum/index.php/topic,75237.msg2848294.html#msg2848294
http://www.newcastle-online.org/nufcforum/index.php/topic,67212.msg2164056.html#msg2164056

[Numbers]

He bottled it bigtime , Pardew said he said "the ref said he didnt have the ball under control therefore it wasnt a goalscoring opportunity", clearly was a goalscoring opportunity like f***ing goon.

[Beren]

We're conceding penalties for fun at the moment.
Chelsea
Citeh x 2
Stoke
Blackburn
Spurs

[geordieglory]

Gary Cahill sent off for fouling Scott Parker as the last man in the Tottenham game.  Parker was 40 yards from goal at the time.

Oh the irony.

 

[Heneage]

Everyone says that Serie A is bent, but at least they admit it. Folk like Dean are what's wrong with the highest level referee's in this country. People like him and Webb spend so long trying to play the big man and not pander to the home team they end up being useless.

[Pilko]

Ryan Taylor should have been sent off for that tackle on Sturridge at the end, like. We got away with that (well, not really cos Santon would play if he had been red carded).

[cp40]

Refs favour the champions league darlings.

[ShearMagic]

Time for video replays.

The referees are too incompetent.

[summerof69]

I think people are overreacting, tbh. Today was an awful performance from Mike Dean, but over the season it hasn't been too bad, atleast not for us, i mean we even got a penalty at Old  Trafford.

[Spider Jerusalem]

He bottled it bigtime , Pardew said he said "the ref said he didnt have the ball under control therefore it wasnt a goalscoring opportunity", clearly was a goalscoring opportunity like f***ing goon.

He didn't get the ball under control because he was chopped down by the last defender before he could run onto a fantastic through ball that was a couple of feet away from him.  As soon as he's given the free kick in that situation he has to give a red, and would have if it was any team not on the FAs wanking list.

[tmonkey]

Agree with Dean tbh, Ba would either have miscontrolled the ball or clumsily lumbered into the keeper so it doesn't really constitute a chance.

[LucaAltieri]

That Blackburn goal vs Wigan.

[Hanshithispantz]

Agree with Dean tbh, Ba would either have miscontrolled the ball or clumsily lumbered into the keeper so it doesn't really constitute a chance.

[timeEd32]

I think people are overreacting, tbh. Today was an awful performance from Mike Dean, but over the season it hasn't been too bad, atleast not for us, i mean we even got a penalty at Old  Trafford.

Yeah, on an abortion of a decision. 

[JH]

summerof69 rewrites the phrases book!

It seems two wrongs do make a right...

[palnese]

There's not a single decent ref in this league.

[TaylorJ_01]

http://www.newcastle-online.org/nufcforum/index.php/topic,91078.msg3359323.html#msg3359323

[OpenC]

It was a red card or no foul.  There was no circumstance in which that could possibly have been just a booking, IMHO.

[summerof69]

summerof69 rewrites the phrases book!

It seems two wrongs do make a right...

What i'm trying to say is that over the season it hasn't been too bad, so that maybe as i said we are over reacting to this.