Topic: Worst ever Newcastle midfielder?

[54]

Me and my brother have just been discussing this, was wondering what people thought? He thinks it'll be Joselu due to the the sample size, where as I think someone like Xisco.

So who do people think is the worst ever NUFC striker?

[neesy111]

For me it's between Rivere, Paul Robinson, Paul Dalglish.

[jonny1403]

Rivière wins this hands down. Joselu is shocking but at least has contributed something (and scored a really good goal at the start of this season). Rivierie literally only managed to score by accident.

[Minhosa]

Guivarche cant be far off that list.

[chopey]

Riviere had the weakest shot ever, he couldn't kick the top off a mushroom

[Collage]

Riviere or Luuk de Jong.

Or Ian Rush

[gbandit]

Riviere again for me. Somehow f***ed up golden opportunities, offered so little in every department. No redeeming qualities

[Mattoon]

Xisco was probably one of the worst buys but he didn't get enough playing time to deem him the worst. We've had some stinkers over the years, Paul Robsinson, Paul Dalglish, Stephan Guivarc'h, Andreas Andersson, Shefki Kuqi, Albert Luque, there's no shortage of utter s**** there!

[toon25]

Riviere had the weakest shot ever, he couldn't kick the top off a mushroom

 

Totally agree. He offered f*** all.

[triggs]

Riviere had the weakest shot ever, he couldn't kick the top off a mushroom

Luuk de Jong's was weaker

[WarrenBartonCentrePartin]

For me it's between Rivere, Paul Robinson, Paul Dalglish.

Hard to disagree with this triumvirate of s***, in my lifetime at least.

Guivarc'h and Andreas Andersson were also f***ing abysmal.

[Jinky Jim]

How about Billy Whitehurst, Billy Askew, Ray Clarke or Tony Cunningham.

[Big Geordie]

Rob McDonald - signed from PSV (I think) after a scouting mission led by then chariman, Gordon McKeag in 1988. He was a bag of s****.

[Big Geordie]

How about Billy Whitehurst, Billy Askew, Ray Clarke or Tony Cunningham.

Clarke was before my time (just!)
Askew was a midfielder?
Whitehurst was a mentalist
Cunningham - not gifted by any means, but he always put in 100%

[Inferior Acuña]

Guivarche was here for about a month and scored a goal, don't think he deserves to be there. Riviere's definitely up there.

[shakey jake]

Joselu is absolutely shocking, pips Rivière to the crown

[TheHoob]

Riviere had the weakest shot ever, he couldn't kick the top off a mushroom

 

[David Edgar]

I feel a bit for de Jong.  He was clearly asked to do a job he wasn't cut out for.

[godzilla]

Worst one by a mile was Rob McDonald. We have had as many s*** strikers as great ones, with Josely in the s*** category although there is some worse.

[godzilla]

How about Billy Whitehurst, Billy Askew, Ray Clarke or Tony Cunningham.

Not a striker

[Minhosa]

I feel a bit for de Jong.  He was clearly asked to do a job he wasn't cut out for.

Kicking a ball over 4mph?

[Tribesman]

Joselu is absolutely shocking, pips Rivière to the crown

Joselu is far better than Riverie. 

[chopey]

How about Billy Whitehurst, Billy Askew, Ray Clarke or Tony Cunningham.

Not a striker

I caught him once and he gave me three wishes in exchange for his freedom.

[Klaus]

Joselu has at least scored a few decent goals, Riv scored what, one goal in the league? A miss kick as well

[shakey jake]

One at palace one at QPR weren’t it?